Days Owners
Days Owners

© 2026 Days Owners

Ownership· 5 min

Why what's yours feels worth more: the psychology of owning something

2 November 2026

Why what's yours feels worth more: the psychology of owning something

A coffee mug, a birthday and a flat-pack box teach the same lesson: we value what we feel is ours more, even when no one else sees it that way. We review the experiments behind it and what they say about symbolic ownership.

The mug nobody wanted to sell

Imagine someone gives you a coffee mug. It is worth a few euros, it is identical to the ones in the shop on the corner, and ten minutes ago you didn't know it existed. Now they ask: how much would you sell it for? And the person next to you, who has no mug, is asked: how much would you pay for one just like it? The two numbers usually do not match. And they are not close.

This is, almost literally, what psychologists and economists Daniel Kahneman, Jack Knetsch and Richard Thaler did in 1990 with students at Cornell University. Some participants were handed a mug with the university logo; others were not. Those who received it asked, at the median, roughly twice what the buyers were willing to pay (around $5.25 against a range of $2.25 to $2.75). If value depended only on the object, half the mugs would have changed hands toward whoever liked them most. There was hardly any trading.

A name for the phenomenon

The phenomenon is known as the endowment effect, a term Thaler had already coined in 1980. The usual explanation connects with loss aversion: giving up something we have hurts more than the equivalent satisfaction of acquiring it. In other words, once something enters the "mine" category, the reference point from which we value it shifts.

It is worth being honest: the effect is neither universal nor constant. Later research has shown that it depends on the type of object, on how the experiment is set up, and on the participant's experience with markets. But the idea that a sense of belonging alters valuation is among the most replicated in behavioral economics.

It is enough for it to be "mine"

An earlier study by psychologist James Beggan (1992) went further: not even a strong bond is required. In his experiments, participants rated an object more favorably simply because it had been assigned to them, which was dubbed the mere ownership effect. It did not matter that the object was ordinary; what mattered was that it was theirs.

What we have built, we value more

There is a second ingredient: effort. In 2012, Michael Norton, Daniel Mochon and Dan Ariely published the experiments behind the so-called IKEA effect in the Journal of Consumer Psychology. Participants who assembled a flat-pack box themselves valued it more than those who received a pre-assembled one; in their tests, they paid more for their own work even when it was worse than an expert's. We value what we have touched, chosen or built.

The numbers and letters we feel are ours

Belonging is not limited to physical things. In 1997, Shinobu Kitayama and Mayumi Karasawa published a study in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin with Japanese participants: they rated numbers that appeared in their birthday more favorably than other numbers. This is the so-called birthday-number effect, a cousin of the "name-letter effect", in which we prefer the letters of our own name. Later work (Jones, Pelham and colleagues, 2002 and 2004) found results along the same lines, although some of the most eye-catching conclusions, such as people moving to towns whose names contain their birthday number, have been questioned by other researchers.

The underlying idea is clear: a date, a number or a letter, something with no physical value, can be part of our identity. And when something is part of our identity, we defend it.

So what about the symbolic?

If the endowment effect worked only with tangible objects, a symbolic title should not produce it. But the evidence suggests that the key is not the weight of the object but the feeling that it is ours, that it is unique, and that there is a story tying us to it. It happens with star names, commemorative plaques, a theater seat with our name on it, a park bench dedicated to someone. Nobody buys them for their usefulness.

It is also worth separating personal valuation from market value. That something is worth more to the person who owns it does not mean others will pay the same. The endowment effect explains why selling is hard, not why someone would pay more. It is a bias to be aware of, not a guarantee of anything.

Closing: the value of saying "mine"

The Cornell mug teaches us something that goes beyond economics: value does not live only in things but in the relationship we have with them. Sometimes a birthday, a name or the simple act of choosing is enough to turn something ordinary into ours. Perhaps that is why there are so many ways of owning the intangible, and so many people willing to defend them.


Sources: Kahneman, Knetsch and Thaler, "Experimental Tests of the Endowment Effect and the Coase Theorem", Journal of Political Economy, 1990; Thaler, "Toward a positive theory of consumer choice", 1980; Beggan, "On the social nature of nonsocial perception: the mere ownership effect", JPSP, 1992; Norton, Mochon and Ariely, "The IKEA effect", Journal of Consumer Psychology, 2012; Kitayama and Karasawa, "Implicit self-esteem in Japan: name letters and birthday numbers", PSPB, 1997; Birthday-number effect (Wikipedia).

← Back to Journal